• NME.COM
  • Saturday, 22 November 2008
NEW!

NME Reviews

Coldplay

Viva La Vida Or Death And All His Friends

Why is it that all major league UK rock bands end up turning into U2? Has Bono personally impregnated every arena dressing room with his juices so anyone within 20 feet catches Big Music like scabies? Coldplay began to show symptoms with The Edge-aping guitar desertscape bit on ‘Fix You’ and on this, their fourth studio album, they develop full Bono Bombast Syndrome. Sheesh, what next? Can we expect Chris Martin to grow wrap-around shades and lose four feet from his height by Christmas? An obvious comparison maybe, but Coldplay are the band most likely to be offended by it. They’ve dressed up like 19th century French army peasants ready to storm the musical Bastille in NME. They’ve slapped a stirring painting of Gallic death or glory on their album sleeve. They’re saying they want a Coldplay revolution. They probably thought ‘Lovers In Japan’, a jaunty piano rollock drenched in enough ‘Joshua Tree’ reverb to demolish Red Rocks, was a searing sonic battle between Echo & The Bunnymen, The Cocteau Twins and A Place To Bury Strangers. They yearn to be recast as outsiders violently opposed to the mainstream hegemony but can’t see that by dint of their incessant knack for a stadium-sized chorus they’re so deeply entrenched in the mainstream that they’re our men on the inside, making the most offensive indie racket palatable to the masses with a sprinkle of their melodic fairy dust.

Case in point: when they say they’ve been influenced by My Bloody Valentine and point to the guitar screes and hazy, unintelligible vocals of ‘Chinese Sleep Chant’, they fail to realise the angelic hooklines they’ve couched within the noisefest make the song as mainstream as ‘Umbrella’. It may prompt a million Tarquins to lob hummus at the stereo in disgust but, tellingly, not once during Coldplay’s most adventurous song to date will you phone Apple to complain your iTunes is fucked. See, they don’t have it in them to be Radiohead, making nice-but-vaguely-difficult records for 30-something £50 Men who want to feel ‘cutting edge’ while only buying one record a year, nor would we want them to. Because they are fantastic at what they do, ie sneaking alternative culture into the nation’s subconscious while pretending to be dinner party music. And ‘Viva La Vida…’, like the much-maligned (by the band anyway) ‘X&Y’, is a brilliant collection of songs designed to push Coldplay’s epic envelope far enough to avoid stagnation while never scaring the Nissan-driving horses.

It takes a while to get going, sure: the electro-world-pop instrumental opener ‘Life In Technicolor’ seems superfluous until it’s repeated with vocals as the secret track at the end, while the dark Dubliner throb of ‘Cemeteries Of London’ sounds suspiciously like a Riverdance Halloween special; Martin crooning about night creatures, broken curses, witches and ghost towns while Jonny Buckland’s guitar slices like the softest of Sweeney Todd’s razorblades. It’s not until ‘Lost!’ – all church organ funkiness, stomporific handclap rhythms and Chris pouting like a preacher in a jacuzzi full of strippers – that ‘Viva…’ really hits its stride. ‘42’ opens like a Coldplay piano classic à la ‘Trouble’ with Martin bewailing the voices in his head like a sanatorium balladeer, then breaks into a freewheeling college rock stormer. ‘Lovers In Japan’ provides stadium pop relief and the delicate ‘Reign Of Love’ (complete with Buckland hitting his guitar with an anvil far off in the distance) is as tender as any costume-drama sex scene featuring Kevin Costner unravelling Kate Winslet’s corsets on rolling Irish heathland.

But it’s in its latter stages that ‘Viva…’ truly goes stratospheric: on the magnificent orchestral pop title track, where Martin imagines himself as a deposed French king reduced to sweeping the streets; on the bruised ‘Yes’, like Dandy Warhols and Depeche Mode lost in a desert duststorm; on the Satanic blues hymnal of single ‘Violet Hill’. As the record rounds up with the thumping ceilidh of ‘Strawberry Swing’ and the disjointed Elbow-ish crescendo of ‘Death And All His Friends’ you can only applaud Coldplay’s daring within their Big Music remit. ‘Viva…’, like those revolutionary French peasants at the palace gates, is steeped in traditionalism (Irish folk, Deep South country and blues, churchy classicism) but striving for something greater, grander, better. And with mainstream success guaranteed, by over-reaching themselves Coldplay are perfectly placed to decree the shape of the new rock order with album five. King Bono is dead; long live the kings.

Mark Beaumont

Coldplay - 'Viva la Vida Or Death And All His Friends' available now from the NME Store.

8 out of 10

Comments (63)

Add a comment

interpolluter28 

Jun 1, 2008

You know? WHen I read this review, I could not stop thinking about that first line? Why does every band that goes big have to be compared to U2?

interpolluter28 

Jun 1, 2008

Not that they were right here, but it's like saying every young British band right now is turning into The Arctic Monkeys.

its_rudimentary 

Jun 1, 2008

what a bag of shit....

liveon35mm 

Jun 1, 2008

is it possibly because a guy called Brian Eno used to be behind the buttons of all important U2 albums and is now on the Coldplay mixer desk?---too easy to shoot Coldplay...they don't deserve my time.---liveon35mm.com

Geo91 

Jun 1, 2008

I find its_rudimentary's dedication to pissing off every Coldplay fan on the planet quite inspiring, good on you. I'm sure this album's gonna be great, but nothing can top A Rush of Blood to the Head.

Rebekahhh 

Jun 1, 2008

I love Coldplay!!! I think this will be their best album yet!!!

Wheelie123 

Jun 2, 2008

rudimentary spends all his time reading coldplay stories.COLDPLAY ARE THE TITS!!! p.s just bought tickets for their tour, why the hell are the gigs all seated?? will still be awesome tho!

carl01 

Jun 2, 2008

Sorry but how can something that reminds you of U2 be awarded an 8/10 rating? I don't understand.

brndtnlsn 

Jun 2, 2008

Great review if I dare say. You think it's going to be one thing, then it's something else. The U2 comparison is used constructively and poignantly.

Soundedd 

Jun 3, 2008

Viva La Vida. Got my tickets for the NIA in Brum on the first night, I'm happy, should be a mint album. I actually prefer bigger seated arena gigs than small academy gigs, good on ya Mr Martin. "If you love me, won't you let me know", love it :)

davis64 

Jun 3, 2008

I'm sorry, but that review is nearly unreadable in parts - trying to fit too many comments and comparisons in a short space. I literally had no idea whether the writer thought the album was good or bad in the first paragraph.

Mark 9:20 

Jun 3, 2008

Is Beaumont writing a novel in his spare time? If so, I am of the belief that he needs more spare time. If Chris Martin and Fucking Bono cared so much about Making Debt Fair, and Dropping The Fair Trade then why are they masquerading as Grey Granite Rock Stars. If they cared so much, they would put their whole fucking life into it, and we wouldn´t even know who they were. They both harp on about a humanitarian quarry of shit when they´re not making music, and then release songs that, ultimately, say nothing about current affairs. For what are they trying to atone? I can tolerate being patronised by them on an average day, but, apropos of what has befallen me today, I think that they should both take a short, soft listen to themselves and shut the fuck up. I do like that cover though.

AdamShanklyUK 

Jun 4, 2008

Isn't Mark Beaumont that bitch who slagged off Interpol...? This can only mean his musical opinion counts for nothing.

bmcvision 

Jun 6, 2008

This review is terrible, I couldn't tell if he likes it or hates it. Enough with the mumbo jumbo and gives us something worth reading. I do enjoy Violet Hill, what I am not enjoying is the promotion through Apple which is incrediably annoying. And these costumes Coldplay is wearing now, come on, just dress like normal people and go back to your bashful whiney selves like you were during "Parachutes" and "Rush..." I have a love/hate relationship with Coldplay and find myself anxiously awaiting June 16th.

NealMaxwell 

Jun 6, 2008

The reason why so many bands aspire to be like U2 is because they are the best band in the world. The fact is that there are tons of bands aspiring to be the next Coldplay and that's because they are a really great band. They haven't yet made a bad album, and Viva La Vida for me will be more enduring than X & Y. It is produced very well and that's part of what makes it such a great album. Every song is placed perfectly and it's like reading a great Novel. You don't want it to end. How do you decide that it's an 8 or a 10 or whatever. It's a fantastic Album and it's a 10.

Mark_Pickering 

Jun 7, 2008

So do you like the album or not? The comparision to U2 is totally unjustified, this album nor the start of the album sounds nothing like U2, using reverb does not mean you're copying the Edge, the song structures, directions and sounds are different to U2 (who are commercialised, overated, big headed idiots) and the only way to bring electric guitars into the songs would be to use reverb because of the orchestrated sounds, which reminded you of U2 and then you thought you'd open up your review with something catchy to keep people reading and you then end up giving the album 8/10, so how can you sound like/imitate U2 and be 8/10 Mark Beaumont? And comparing the opening of '42' to 'Trouble' is very amateur and hopeful.

ragoo88 

Jun 7, 2008

fookin' hell!!!!this review is a bag of dirt....i mean, that whole little jab at Radiohead was just stupid....this album is just pop music trying too hard to be rock.....it's so annoying...i am so glad i have lost interest in Coldplay, it seems like they just keep going down hill with each album...trying to make a statement with horrid lyrics and an awfully annoying voice.....urgh!!!

story-teller 

Jun 7, 2008

I cannot believe this review!!!!!!!!! Did the guy even listen to the album? Having heard the Viva la Vida myself I can tell people that it’s a 10 out of 10 album!! The comparison to u2 (that was so obvious and deserved on x&y) has no place in this review. This is coldplay doing something different and succeeding. I am in no way a coldplay fanboy or a hater of u2 but this is what U2 wish they could sound like. It’s not instantly gratifying and then forgetful. You get out what you put in and this is the best album I’ve heard since Artic Monkeys! I’m so mad because I have rarely read an nme review that I didn’t think was pretty much on the money, and I honestly expected a 10. After reminding myself that the score matters not as long as the review is accurately written, I read the review in disbelief, it’s just plain wrong. A friend of mine was put off by the reviews comparison to U2. I lent him the album and he cannot understand the review either – end of rant.

GregMartin 

Jun 8, 2008

If that is the best review the editor could find for the biggest album since In Rainbows, then I think NME seriously needs an overhaul. Far too many references to other bands and quite a lot of ambiguous adjectives that made me wonder whether Mark Beaumont was even listening to the same album that I am. I am very happy with Coldplay's about-turn of musical direction as I for one was disappointed with X&Y, which might as well have been 'Speed and Sound' repeated twelve times. I love the South Asian influences that clearly come through in Lost! and Life in Technicolor. To compare this to ANY of Coldplay's previous works is tantamount to calling Kid A 'similar' to Pablo Honey.10/10 See you in October, Chris et al.

its_rudimentary 

Jun 8, 2008

I cannot believe the arrogance of many of the posters that are arguing that the album should have got 10/10 what are you on about? The NME has been far too generous in the past awarding this mark to some distinctly average Coldplay albums and for gods sake 8/10 thats hardly a rippin is it, get a grip and wind your necks in. To achieve 10/10 surely an album has got to bring something new and inspiring to the table and to be frank this album does neither. And as for the U2 comparison spot on, middle of the road over the counter supermarket no1 rubbish spouting crap about saving the world.

carrot cruncher 

Jun 8, 2008

Yeah you could be right it could be pop music it could be any music you like but its still an amazing album and i cant believe any one who has heard it with an open mind can can state othewise

carrot cruncher 

Jun 9, 2008

Why do you call it arrogance when you take the piss out of every coldplay article that is posted, just stateing our opinion like you, deal with you twat 10/10 for viva

its_rudimentary 

Jun 9, 2008

OK fair point maybe I should substitute the word arrogant with deluded.....please 10/10 your having a joke it is nothing special. Fair enough Coldplay's music brings you summat that don't to me but get realistic in terms of music it aint amazing it aint sgt peppers and no way deserves 10/10

carrot cruncher 

Jun 9, 2008

And why the fuck do you think you have a right to call me deluded because i dont agree with what you say.I have heard the album 4 times now and you are right the beauty of music is that it does bring different people different things. If i thought it was shit i would say it but idont not one track that i did not like so thats how ican say 10/10 . Oh i think the nme score is closer to mine than yours what was it BAG OF SHIT

sonneteers 

Jun 10, 2008

This is the weakest Coldplay album to date in my opinion. I think the reviewer is just basing his rating of 8/10 on Coldplay's past triumphs. I they've really lost their direction and it shows on this record. (sorry coldplay fans)

lewis08arcticmonkeys 

Jun 10, 2008

Whoever writes these reviews is a joke. Your reviewing an album, not showing off your writing skills. Sort the life out like. Coldplay - Viva La Vida, Proper good album. Not as good as A Ruch Of Blood To The Head but its right up there.

PMoore1981 

Jun 11, 2008

all you lot who claim to hate coldplay why even take time out your day to come on here and state this?? surely a person of such sound, strong mind wouldnt waste their time discussing something they detest so much? Take yer heads out yer arses, the music is genius & it appeals to you, but because more than 8 people enjoy it you cant be a part of that for fear of not being individual enough!! Coldplay have surpassed themselves witht this album! An album that plays from the 1st track to the last with ease never dissapointing! It cant be listenened to once without it having to be immediately put back on! 10/10

wowzer555 

Jun 13, 2008

i love coldplay. i think they are great. always have. but this time i fear, eno has broken it. no real songs, no soul. and the one thing that makes them them - chris's voice is processed to shit and sounds at best average. it will still sell millions but if (for emi) it was all resting on this artistically i'd say they were screwed.

carrot cruncher 

Jun 13, 2008

Well said mr p moore couldnt agree more. I bet when coldplay first came out most off these muppets who criticize them now loved them but as soon as others thought the same they changed their tune.

listenasthewindblows.. 

Jun 14, 2008

A confused review.. not confusing, just confused. The comparisons and references to U2 are distracting and unneccessary. The creative and elloquent bullshit in this review is a waste of the readers time and effort. My personal opinion is that 'Viva la vida' is an emotionally absorbing and rewarding work of art... not everyone will agree.. but there is humility in clarity.

mancdownsouth 

Jun 16, 2008

Proof that you should never look forward to an album by one of your favourite bands! Maybe it's a reaction to the global domination of 'X&Y', but it seems Eno and Dravs have encouraged the band to disappear up their own muso backsides and come up with 20-odd ideas and half-songs, many of them welded together as reliably as 'cut-and-shut' cars. Much of it sounds beautiful, some of it quite challenging, a few attempts at hooks, but the overall effect is soporific. Guys, can we have a proper song or two please next time?OK but unmemorable, 'Viva La Vida' will probably join the pile of great missed opportunities in a few weeks. The only good point - it will encourage me to revisit the first 3 albums to remind me what made Coldplay a great band in the first place!

tetsuo87000 

Jun 16, 2008

8 out of 10 for an album wich sounds like the last (shitty) U2's, vous êtes vraiment con des fois les anglais

rick 13 

Jun 16, 2008

im sorry people but i think coldplay are a very boring and dull band with nothing to say, 1st album i thought was very good, 2nd i was like, well ok but i wanna listen to music, not a moaning man who sounds like a dog howling, 3rd album i was like ok time to call it a day, this album they can just fuck off, go play cricket and be an eco warrior.

jimmyjones123 

Jun 16, 2008

does anybody else think there is element of tears for fears in life in technicolour (head over heals).. lost has the same beat as shout...listen to it

steuph1976 

Jun 16, 2008

How about this review :Band explodes playing too many great tunes at the same time.11/10

joseph_keane 

Jun 17, 2008

i think the record is absolutly brilhant the best of the band so far and probably the record of the year 10 out of 10.

Orangeboy 

Jun 18, 2008

Just listened to the album, and sadly I think it is a load of self indulgent twaddle. I was excited by the press reviews (must learn never to trust any reviews) saying it was better than X and Y but it is not in the same league, and sounds like a band that has lost their mojo. People criticised X and y for being too commercial, but what is too commercial? catchy songs? I'd prefer catchy well written songs to this noise. Viva la vida is the only song that it is bearable to listen to, but they couldn't be bothered with the rest of it. I am upset, because I thought Coldplay were the band that could emulate the likes of Pink Floyd, and other greats, but they have let me down. you have to wonder when the first track on an album is an instrumental... Get ur heads out of your bottom boys! And dressing up like french revolutionaries, give me a break. Too much money, and too much praise, in the end it destroys the essence of all bands.

stevieg94 

Jun 18, 2008

Coldplay are boring and are just a bunch of posh w@nkers to be honest! Just give me an Oasis album and a bag of weed and il be much happier! What's the point in listening to poofy rock like tht when ya can listen to the sound of a council estate singing its heart out with no nonsense, rough round the edges rock n roll! Thats music for ya! Parachutes= boring! Arobtth= boring! X and Y = ok! Viva la vida= St. chris is a cheeky bastard for sendin out a record like tht.

mrharmonica 

Jun 18, 2008

Some good comments guys but some really pish unproductive stuff aswell. Lets face it even if you do not like them, there a quality band, time will tell if 'Viva La Vida' will stand as one one of there great achievements. Some brilliant pianos and guitars, all be it yes I do agree some of the songs are cheese but there a feel good band and with it have to appeal to a large crowd. Generally this is the same with U2 which is where I can see the similarities. Point blank even if you dont like it, these boys are here to stay

listenasthewindblows.. 

Jun 19, 2008

What's going on here??!!! Stevieg94 just keep quiet and give us all a break.. this is an album that represents a unique moment in british popular rock music. What Coldplay have achieved here is a 'leap' in what was expected of them and as such they will not recieve the proper and appropriate credit untill much later on in time.. and i hope it comes much sooner than later..

listenasthewindblows.. 

Jun 19, 2008

I guess the only shame about this album is that 'lovers in japan' is so badly produced that it kills your ears if listened to on headphones! Bad production on an album this big is unforgivable..

carrot cruncher 

Jun 19, 2008

Stevieg oasis are past coldplay are present and what the fuck has them being posh [they are not] got to do with music. Im working class but can relate more to coldplay than oasis and that monkey arm swinging cunt Liam Gallagher. Face facts mate oasis are no longer the biggest band in the uk coldplay are

joeld 

Jun 19, 2008

Whatever you think of the album you have to applaud them for not taking the easy route and making 'X & Y' 2.

Joely Boy 

Jun 19, 2008

I cant compare with there other albums cous iv havent heard them but its a good album but on 1 or 2 tracks theres 2 songs in 1 track its quite anoying. Best song Viva La Vida

TheMoss 

Jun 20, 2008

PLEASE stop comparing Coldplay to U2, to be honest it does my head in. They are a completely different band, and in my opinion streets ahead of U2. I know this might sound controversial, but U2 are the most overrated band in history, I havent heard all of the new album, but if its anything close to Parachutes, Rush of Blood or the majestic X and Y then Coldplay deserve to be ranked as one of the greatest bands of all time, long live Coldplay

TheMoss 

Jun 20, 2008

stevieg94, I suggest you listen to Rush of Blood to the Head stoned, Iam sure it will change your mind

Jacoblandelius 

Jun 23, 2008

No, they don't sound very like U2. Tho Chris Martin himself has said that he is a huge U2 fan. Btw i love, i mean love both bands, tho if U2 is a 10 in the studio, Coldplay is a 10, if Colplay is a 10 live, U2 is a 1 000 000, not saying Coldplay is bad live (seen both bands) in fact, they are flawless, but when seeing a U2 concert, it makes you religious, it's ... well can't be described with words, that's why U2 is the greatest band on earth :P Tho i like Coldplay very much too.

riverboat song 

Jun 23, 2008

coldplay are an average band with average music, nothing more... give me oasis any day!!!

its_rudimentary 

Jun 24, 2008

Coldplay are so bland, watched them on BBC 2 live and it was dire, music for souless drones. Oasis whilst past their peak (last album was better than this Viva shit) have more soul, charisma and tunes than Coldplay ever have had, ultimately whose better live? Oasis without question. Carrotcruncher needs to open his eyes and stop deep throating vegetables cos I think that is affecting his judgement, what a twat he is.

Orangeboy 

Jun 25, 2008

I think comparing Oasis and coldplay is like comparing chalk and cheese, Pink Floyd or Led Zeppellin. Completely different bands. I really don't like Viva la Vida as I mentioned earlier but at least Coldplay are trying to move forward (albeit in completely the wrong direction). Oasis lost their soul to the devil a long time ago, and are nothing more than a slick money making machine belting out the same 3 chords in various orders. And I have nothing against them, that's what too much money does for you! It happens to all bands, they all sell out. I mean how relevant is Liam singing " Is it worth the agrivation to find yourself a job when there's nothing worth working for?" You've had a preety good job for 15 years now mate. Your days of being on the dole in burnage are well and truly over! I also find Liam Gallagher's obsession with John Lennon to be boring now, in fact it has always been boring. Oasis are a great band though, but they stopped being relevant on the 21st August 1997 when Be Here Now was released. As a fan I was always hoping for their next

TheMoss 

Jun 25, 2008

Finally bought this album today, 1st impressions I am not too sure about it, maybe its a grower need to listen a few more times, on initial listening though disappointed

carrot cruncher 

Jun 26, 2008

Rudimentary why do you bother?Dire music for souless drones yet you watched them.I dont need to open my eyes prick because i listen with my ears,something you should try

cops are robbers 

Jun 28, 2008

Went to HMV and got my money back for this excuse of an album.........Another band who sold out to the suits.

27Club 

Jun 30, 2008

Ok so I've read through all the comments here and I would have to say I'm torn. There is no way this is a 10/10 but at the same time I don't think 8/10 is stretching it too far. Although that's on a good day. What we have here is definitely a mainstream attempt at art but I don't think that's a bad thing. Sure these four lads are trying to reach beyond themselves with this one. Sure their trademarks emerge from time to time. But that is what being a band is all about. You develop a sound and then you want to shake your binds but everything you know and have developed is in those very binds. Personally I think the thing that holds Coldplay back is the very thing that people hold up as their guiding light... Chris Martin's voice. The difference between Coldplay and U2 is the voice. The quality that held Bono's voice apart (at least up until about '97) was that it sounded like it had no limit. Like there was no top and it could just continue up and up. Lift the sky and all of that. The problem is you can hear

Cecily Parsley 

Jul 2, 2008

I wrote a review on it here: http://pulpaddiction.co.uk/2008/06/16/viva-la-vida-review/

Moosh2k7 

Jul 4, 2008

Coldplay are ridiculously better than Oasis. They may be a bit pretentious but who isn't? As 27Club said it's a good thing that a band is trying to stretch beyond themselves, if every band stayed within their limits we'd currently be stuck with a terrible amount of recycled guitar rock bands who are exact doubles of Oasis.They certainly pulled this album off.

rick 13 

Jul 5, 2008

coldplay better than oasis?!?!?!NO FUCKIN WAY!!!

clashgt 

Jul 6, 2008

main point Viva la vida is the best album in the year so far

be your own pet fucker 

Jul 10, 2008

Its good but i found it hard to lissten to.

clarky22 

Jul 18, 2008

this album takes a few listens but will be up there as the album of the year its genius,headliners for t in the park next year am hopin

carlin_bbz 

Jul 26, 2008

Coldplay wish they were U2. Its always been that way. They tried to go beyond themselves with this and it fell flat in my opinion.The Subways "All or Nothing" is the album of the year. Go listen to that and tell me Vida la vida can even compare.

tamoratvr 

Jul 31, 2008

So many comments....Who will read mne?I used to think this band sublime...think clocks...the scientist...and now numbers and figures to endeavours.....of white rock filled stadia.....disappointed to see chris already shopping for Bono style sunglasses....must be all those apples he keeps buying....or perhaps all that big superstar Gynneth he keeps eating....

lucky_7s 

Aug 26, 2008

This review is an absolute disgrace! This is the best album i have heard since 'in rainbows'...Viva La Vida is unlike any Coldplay album and even any U2 album i have heard - the guitaring is very unlike of Coldplay and reminds me slight of Jonny Greenwood. I dont know about you Beaumont, but have you heard an album that contains a Hammered Dulcimer (life in technicolor) and makes it sounds fooking fantastic - this album is a masterpiece, unlike anything theyve ever produced, and anyone else for that matter

Add your comment

NME Alerts

Get NME news delivered direct to your desktop. Find out more

This Week's Issue
  • NME Magazine - The ultimate guide to the week in music
  • The ultimate guide to the week in music
  • NME Magazine - Subscribe now and save up to £45!
Please sign in

Forgot your password?

Register with MyNME

Every Tuesday and Friday

  • Up-to-the-minute news stories
  • The best new music and free downloads
  • Video interviews, photo galleries, competitions and more
  • Album and track reviews for the week ahead
  • Essential gigs in your area